Canadian Historic Sites: Occasional Papers in Archaeology and History No. 6
The Excavation and Historical Identification of Rocky Mountain House
by William C. Noble
Artifact Descriptions (continued)
PERSONAL AND HOUSEHOLD ITEMS
The following table represents a synthesis of the artifacts from
Rocky Mountain House ascribable to personal or house hold use. As a
unit, 14 different commodities are represented despite the fact that
they constitute only 1.8 per cent of the total artifact sample. The clay
pipes are included as personal items rather than trade articles because
of their low frequency and restricted proveniences.
Pipes
The fragments of clay pipes recovered during excavation include bowl
and stem portions, some of which were possible to mend and reconstruct.
In the following the author's analysis is complemented by comments from
a report made by the late Mr. H. Gieger Omwake (1964) who examined some
of the typical specimens from Rocky Mountain House through a series of
photographs.
Table 1: Personal and Household Items |
Item | Number |
|
Clay pipe bowls and fragments | 25 |
|
Clay pipe stem fragments | 104 |
|
Buttons | 27 |
|
Cuff-links | 1 |
|
Lead cross | 1 |
|
Earrings | 3 |
|
Watch winder | 1 |
|
Hawk bells | 2 |
|
Copper arm band or bracelet | 1 |
|
Needles | 4 |
|
Pins | 1 |
|
Forks | 2 |
|
Glass vials | 2 |
|
Glass bottles | 5 |
|
Glass bottle fragments | 17 |
|
Ceramic fragments | 9 |
|
Total | 205 |
|
42 Banglers and pipe fragments, a, two large nested
brass banglers from building III; b, two smaller
brass banglers; c, clay pipe bowl with TD spur and
TD scroll on back; d, complete bowl from pit 8 with
TD on spur; e, bowl portion with TD on spur; f-g,
flat-based and unlettered pipe bowls.
(click on image for a PDF version)
|
Pipe Bowls
A total of 25 pipe bowl fragments was recovered during excavation,
five of which represent intact or semi-intact specimens suitable for
detailed examination. Classification of these five bowls reveals three
distinct types, two of which are variations of the TD pipe.
Type 1. Flat-Based and Unlettered. This bowl type is
represented by two excava ted specimens (Fig. 42, f-g). The base
of the bowl has no projecting spur, and the bowl as a whole is devoid of
any distinguishing maker's mark or lettering. On one of the specimens,
mottled blue transfer paint appears on the lower portion of the bowl and
adjoining stem segment; the other specimen is completely plain. Both
bowls project obtusely from the stem at an angle of about 105 degrees;
they also have a bowl height of 4 cm. and measure 2.1 cm. in diameter.
The provenience of the two excavated specimens, recovered close to one
another, was south of the double-hearth fireplace in the central area of
building II, a building attributable to the Hudson's Bay Company
occupation of the fort (1821-34).
Type 2. Spurred and Scroll TD. Two specimens of this type of
TD pipe are represented in the Rocky Mountain House bowl sample (Fig.
42, c). The type is characterized by a projecting basal spur on which the
letters T and D are impressed in relief on opposite sides. When the pipe
bowl is held in vertical smoking position the letter T appears on the
left side of the spur and the letter D on the right. In addition, this
bowl type has a hand-impressed stamp on the back of the bowl facing the
smoker. The design of this stamp includes a circle within which are the
two letters T and D accompanied by scroll-like floral ornamentation both
above and below the letters. The bowl projects from the stem at an angle
of 110 degrees, measures 2 cm. in diameter and has a height of 2.4 cm.
This height is noticeably less than that of bowl type 1, described
above.
One of the specimens of this type of TD pipe was found within the
south central area of building II, while the other was recovered in the
open area between building II and the north corner bastion.
Type 3. Spurred TD. One complete specimen of this variety of
TD pipe concludes the analyzable sample of pipe bowls (Fig. 42, d).
This type is characterized by having a completely plain bowl. This spur is
identical to that described above for bowl type 2, and similarly has the
impressed letters T and D in relief on opposite sides. The bowl
protrudes from the stem at an angle of 110 degrees, measures 2.1 cm. in
diameter, and has a height of 3.4 cm. The provenience of this specimen
in pit 8 just outside the south gateway of the extended fort indicates
that this pipe was in use and discarded during the Hudson's Bay Company
occupation of the fort.
Table 2: Concentration of Clay Pipe Bowl Portions |
Provenience | Number |
|
Building II | 7 |
|
Building II (pit 4) | 2 |
|
Building II (pit 15) | 1 |
|
Building V | 1 |
|
North corner bastion | 1 |
|
South gateway | 1 |
|
North corner of fort | 1 |
|
Open centre of fort | 1 |
|
Pit 2 | 3 |
|
Pit 8 | 1 |
|
Pit 10 | 1 |
|
Pit 11 (ash fill) | 5 |
|
Total | 25 |
|
In addition to the 5 analyzable bowl portions, 20 other fragments
were found at Rocky Mountain House. None could be joined together, but
their distribution proves useful. Considered together with the five
analyzable specimens, the distribution of pipe bowl fragments shows a
close association with the buildings and refuse pits situated around the
north, east and southeast perimeters of the fort. This evidence supports
the inference that these were the main areas of habitation within the
fort where pipes were smoked, broken and discarded. The following
tabulation lists the distributive concentrations of pipe bowls and
fragments at Rocky Mountain House.
Pipe Stems
Much more numerous in number than the pipe bowl fragments are the 104
recovered portions of pipe stems from Rocky Mountain House. Of these
fragments, 86 represent mid-stem sections, 15 are mouth pieces and 3 are
badly fragmented stem-bowl junctures.
As with the bowl fragments, a plotting of the distribution of stem
pieces from the fort is of interest. A similar close association of the
stem fragments to pits and buildings is noted (see Table 3).
Without exception, all the stem fragments are devoid of any maker's
mark or moulded stamp. Two specimens, however, both found along the east
wall of the north corner bastion, display the mottled deep blue transfer
painted pattern described previously on one of the type 1 pipe bowls.
These two painted stem fragments do not fit together, but have a
consistent stem bore diameter of 4/64 in.
One other stem fragment, a mouth piece section, has a red paint or
enamel coating over it. This red-tipped stem fragment, 3.6 cm. long by 9
mm. wide, has a bore diameter of 5/64 in. It was recovered loose in the
northwest corner of the fort. Omwake (1964: 16) notes that,
The "red paint or enamel" which appears on one stem fragment is
probably the residue from some substance into which the stems were
dipped to prevent the lips of the smoker from clinging to the clay.
Usually the preparation was a secret known only to a few masters of the
shop. Analysis of one such concretion used in a French pipe factory
about 1775 indicated that protection to the lips was provided by a kind
of wax emulsified in a solution of extremely fine pulverized pipe clay,
soap, gum arabic and water. Probably, all sorts of solutions were
devised for this purpose.
Discussion
Because of the late occupation date of Rocky Mountain House
(1799-1834), measurement of pipe stem bore diameters for dating purposes
is of little use. The pipe stem dating technique, first devised by
Harrington (1954) and later refined by Binford (1961), yields reasonably
accurate results for the period 1620 to 1800; after this time it breaks
down. Tests on the Rocky Mountain House pipe stem bore diameters gave
obviously inaccurate results.
Table 3: Concentration of Clay Pipe Stem Portions |
Provenience | Number |
|
Building I | 10 |
|
Building II | 14 |
|
Building II (pit 4) | 9 |
|
Building II (pit 5) | 1 |
|
Building II (pit 6) | 5 |
|
Building III | 3 |
|
Building III (pit 6) | 13 |
|
Building IV | 6 |
|
Building VI | 3 |
|
North corner bastion | 4 |
|
North corner of fort | 5 |
|
Open centre of fort | 2 |
|
South gateway | 1 |
|
South corner bastion | 1 |
|
Pit 2 | 5 |
|
Pit 3 | 1 |
|
Pit 8 | 1 |
|
Pit 10 | 7 |
|
Pit 11 (ash fill) | 4 |
|
Pit 13 | 1 |
|
Pit 19 | 2 |
|
Outside fort | 6 |
|
Total | 104 |
|
Comparison of the Rocky Mountain House clay pipe bowl specimens with
those recovered from other western forts must necessarily be limited,
due to the fact that most of the historic western sites excavated and
published to date lie south of the 49th parallel in the United States.
Archaeological research on the western forts of Canada is in its
infancy.
The pipe bowls from Rocky Mountain House are distinctly different
from those recovered from American western forts of the 1799-1864
period. Different types of pipes and greater variety appear on the
American sites. In westward progression from the Great Lakes the number
of pipe type varieties decreases. Such differences in kind and degree
are probably associated with differences between the separate trading
companies involved, their sources of supply and the related distances
of transport.
The specific differences and similarities between the Rocky Mountain
House specimens and other western forts are significant. For instance,
at Fort Mackinac (1781-1895) in Michigan, 25 different pipe bowl types
have been identified (Petersen 1963; 7). Only one of these, plain
heelless bowl, conforms to one of the types at Rocky Mountain House.
Similarly, the pipes recovered from Kipp's Post (1826-30) in north
central North Dakota and Fort Lookout II (1831-51) in South Dakota are
quite different. Fort Lookout has three varieties of pipe bowls,
primarily of the WD type (Miller 1960: 65). No such pipes were
encountered at Rocky Mountain House. The Kipp's Post pipes include two
varieties of fluted bowls, two varieties of combined TD wreath - WG spur
bowls, and an ill-defined miscellaneous type. Again, none of these types
appears at Rocky Mountain House, although there are general similarities
in size and shape between the TD bowls from both sites.
Omwake (1964: 5, 9, 12, 13) notes that the varieties of TD pipes from
Rocky Mountain House and Kipp's Post are shorter and squatter, although
not noticeably of smaller diameter than TD pipes recovered from British
campsites of American Revolutionary War provenience. These earlier TD
pipes, he believes, were probably manufactured by Thomas Dormer of
London. It is also evident that the Rocky Mountain House and Kipp's Post
TD pipes are different from the 13-star TDs of the War of 1812, believed
to be patriotic American products. Omwake thus concludes that the Kipp's
Post and Rocky Mountain House TD pipes are of English manufacture.
The available evidence would certainly indicate that the Kipp's Post
TD pipes are an English type. They carry the dual marking of TD and WG,
a practice of probable sales significance, in which a craftsman simply
added his own mark to an already well established mark (Omwake 1964: 8).
The TD mark had acquired a significance unapproached by any other pipe
mark, and eventually became a literal synonym for "white clay pipe."
Omwake (1964: 12) considers William Giles of Liverpool (1802-? ) as the
probable craftsman for the dually marked TD pipes from Kipp's Post. Of
more remote possibility is the less well known Gain and Sons
manufacturer of Hull (1826-? ).
But the Rocky Mountain House TD pipe bowls are neither dually marked
nor as high as the 3.8 cm. (1.5 in.) bowls from Kipp's Post. Bowl
diameters and bowl-stem angles, however, are approximately the same. The
TD pipes from Rocky Mountain House appear from Hudson's Bay Company
contexts while Kipp's Post was an outlet for the Columbia (Tilton) Fur
Company. This latter company was organized by disgruntled employees let
out during the 1821 merger of the Hudson's Bay and North West companies.
Consequently, it is improbable that the Hudson's Bay Company would allow
a competitive rival access to their supplies or that both companies drew
from the same pipe manufacturing source. The question remains, from
where and whom did the Hudson's Bay Company draw their TD pipes such as
appear at Rocky Mountain House?
This question has by no means a certain answer. The Rocky Mountain
House TD pipes date after 1800 and before 1850 when pipe bowl sizes grew
steadily larger and shapes became increasingly more like those of modern
briar pipes (Omwake 1964:13). The pipe proveniences are attributable to
the Hudson's Bay Company occupation of the fort, thereby bracketing a
time period between 1821 and 1834. During this period, there is only one
English manufacturer of TD pipes recorded, Cain and Sons of Hull who set
up shop in 1826 (Omwake 1964:4). But the TD mark was also in use in
Holland where it was controlled by the pipe-makers' guild. The guild
assigned the mark in 1779 to Cornelis Prince, who presumably held it
until 1822 when the mark was reassigned to Johannes de Loos. How long De
Loos used the mark is as yet unknown. Thus there are three possible
makers for the Rocky Mountain House TD pipes from two centres
England or Holland.
The two heelless pipes from the fort might at first glance be
inferred to be early versions of clay pipes because basal spurs are
missing. However, there are three factors suggesting that they date
between 1821 and 1850. First, their provenience is within building II of
Hudson's Bay Company construction; second, these bowls are larger in
height than the TD bowls and more closely resemble modern pipes; third,
one of the specimens exhibits a mottled deep blue transfer paint pattern
characteristic of later pipes. Thus, a date of 1821-50 does not seem
unreasonable for these specimens.
Buttons
The buttons from Rocky Mountain House are among the more sensitive
indicators useful for dating and identifying feature associations,
particularly the Hudson's Bay Company buttons. Unfortunately there is
no standard classification of button types which includes all the
varieties from this site. The general classification by Olsen (1963) is
useful as far as it goes, and to a more limited extent South's (1964)
classification of button types is also applicable. Both sources are
considered in the following button descriptions for the 27 analyzable
specimens excavated.
Sixteen decorated buttons and 11 plain specimens were recovered from
the site. Of the decorated buttons, 10 are silver or silver plate, 2 are
gilded, 1 is of copper, 1 of copper and silver, 1 of
copper and mother of pearl, and 1 of ceramics. Of the plain buttons,
six were iron and five were brass. None of these specimens, either
decorated or plain, has sewing perforations through the disc. In all
cases the buttons are circular.
43 Decorated and plain buttons. a, Hudson's Bay Company;
b, gilt; c, double gilt; d, plated; e,
decorated copper; f, copper and pearl; h, plain
brass, type D; i, plain brass type G; j, plain
iron, drilled eye; k, plain iron with cast boss; l,
plain iron with wire eye.
(click on image for a PDF version)
|
Hudson's Bay Company Dress Buttons.
A total of eight Hudson's Bay Company buttons is represented in the
sample, three of which are of the large coat variety (21 mm. diameter)
and the remainder of cuff or sleeve size (15 mm. diameter). Both button
forms are silver or silver plated, bear the Company insignia on the
outer face, and have the same type of eye attachment.
The Hudson's Bay Company button eye attachments are quite distinctive
and different from any others in the collection. Moulded in one piece
with flat disc back, the foot of the eye attachment is round and rises
in dome-like fashion until cleavage on two sides forms two parallel flat
shelves. These shelves are separated by an upraised dividing portion
into which an iron wire loop eye is inserted.
On the convex outer face of the silver disc is moulded the
distinctive Hudson's Bay Company insignia. A fox seated on his hind
quarters facing the viewer's left sits atop the main crest. This crest,
bounded by two rings of small upraised beads, carries the words PRO
PELLE CUTEM and an elaborately interlaced monogram of the three letters
HBC.
The presence and distribution of the Hudson's Bay Company buttons
concisely establishes a Hudson's Bay Company occupancy at the fort. Two of
the large coat-size specimens come from building II, one from pit 4 and
the other from just west of the double-hearth fireplace. A third large
specimen was found five feet outside the south end of the extended fort.
Of the five smaller versions of Hudson's Bay Company buttons, two also
came from building II. Here one was found in pit 4 while the other was
lying in the central part of the building. The other small Company
buttons turned up between the west end of building II and the north end
of building III. The final specimen was found in the area between
building II and pit 11. Clearly the button associations are direct proof
of the Hudson's Bay Company's occupancy of the fort and residence in
building II.
Gilt Button
A single specimen of a gilt button occurs in the sample (Fig. 43,
b). The disc is small with a diameter of 13 mm. and has a plain,
flat exterior face. Although the disc is of iron, it was once covered
with a thin layer of gold or gold-like substance, hence the occurrence
of the stamped word GILT in capital letters on the flat back of the
button. Below this word further decoration is present on the button's
reverse side. Flanking each of the two side margins is a wreath of
laurel leaves branching in four directions from a central stem.
Underlying these side wreaths in turn are three six-pointed stars,
spaced equidistant from one another, and bordering the bottom of the
button in a position directly opposite the word GILT at the top. These
designs are also stamped within shallow concavities. The well-soldered
iron loop eye is brazed to the disc without any accompanying foot. The
provenience of this gilded button is from pit 5 within building II,
definitely within a Hudson's Bay Company context. As such, it should
date between 1821 and 1834. Ford (1943: 206) remarks that,
The popularity of the gilt buttons lasted from the time of George
III until electrogilding, discovered in 1840, so cheapened the quality
that all demand for them ceased. Electrogilding was not so durable as
the older methods of plating and tarnished more easily, and there is no
wonder these buttons lost their appeal they were an altogether
inferior product.
Double Gilt Button
This single button is very much like that described above except that
its base is brass (Fig. 43, c). Both the obverse and reverse
faces are flat and the disc diameter measures 14 mm. While the obverse
face is devoid of any decoration, the reverse side carries the stamped
signet DOUBLE GILT in capital letters. These words are within two
shallow encircling bands, one separating the words from the outer rim of
the button and the other between them and the wire eye shank. The word
DOUBLE overlies and is separated from the word GILT by an eight-pointed
star at each end of the word. No foot is present on an otherwise
well-soldered eye. This gilded specimen is from the 35 in. depth of pit
10 within building VI.
Plated Button
Another brass button bearing decoration and insignia is represented
in the sample (Fig. 43, d). This small specimen of 14 mm.
diameter has a slightly convex exterior face in the middle of which is a
finely etched star design composed of
eight intersecting thin lines. The lines of this star do not extend
to the button's margin. On the reverse side of the button, seated within
shallow curved depressions, are two other stamped designs in relief. The
uppermost insignia bears the word PLATED in capital letters and is
flanked at either end by an arrow pointing inward toward the word. At
the bottom of this same side of the button in another shallow, curved
depression is a decoration composed of two arrows pointing centrally
toward an intermediate plus sign. Although no evidence remains of a
plating substance over this button, it seems reasonable to believe it was
silver plated as opposed to being gilded. The soldered eye attachment
has no foot.
The provenience of this plated button is from the east end of
building V, known to date to the Hudson's Bay Company occupation of the
fort.
Hollow Silver Button
This button specimen has a very distinctive decoration and method of
manufacture. It is made of a single piece of thin silver foil folded so
as to create a hollow interior concavity between the exterior and
reverse faces of the disc. The diameter of the disc is 17 mm. On the
concave reverse side of the button are two small holes each spaced apart
from one another near the outer margin of the disc. These holes are for
fastening purposes and perhaps imply that the hollow silver disc was
used as a cap or covering over a firmer button base.
The exterior face of the hollow silver disc is ornately embossed.
Fifteen spoke-like segments radiate around the disc from an upraised
central hub, the centre of which is depressed. Around the rim of the button the spokes
separate 15 up raised bulges which complete the exterior moulded design.
No recognizable maker's mark occurs on this artifact.
The provenience of this button or button covering is from within the
north corner bastion; thus it may date to the early period of the fort's
occupancy.
Ceramic Button
This specimen (Fig. 45, e) is more fully described in a later
section on ceramics, under the heading dealing with the decorated
underglazed creamware with transfer printing. Suffice it to state here
that this particular specimen is from within building II near the
double-hearth fireplace; it is, therefore, from a Hudson's Bay Company
context in the fort.
Decorated Copper Button
This button type is represented by a single specimen whose disc is
incomplete (Fig. 43, e). The button, a large one measuring 24 mm.
in diameter, is of copper, cast and moulded in one piece. The reverse
side of the button is flat and plain with a fixed shank square in
section and having a drilled eye.
The exterior face of the button exhibits an ornately embossed
design. Around the outside margin of the disc is a single chain of small
adjacent beads. Within this outer beaded circle is another chain of
beads forming continuous triangular loops 1.5 mm. wide. These beaded
triangles not only touch the outer bead circle but touch each of the
pointed tips of a central heavily raised solid star design. Nine points
of this solid star are preserved, each radiating from a common
ring which encircles the shallow depressed centre of the disc. The
width of the solid star from its interior to the point tips is 6 mm., and
it lies 3 mm. from the centre of the button. Within the depressed
shallow centre of the button there is another star design of eight
radiating lines. These lines are in low relief and radiate from the
exact centre of the button.
This decorated copper button came from pit 8 just outside and to the
east of the south gateway of the rebuilt fort. It is, therefore, in a
context datable to the Hudson's Bay Company occupation.
Copper and Silver Button
A copper and silver button measures 17 mm. in diameter and has a flat
disc of silver inlaid into the copper setting of the exterior face (Fig.
43, f). The silver disc is 15 mm. wide, and other than a few deep
scratches bears no stamp or design. The copper setting has gently
rounded exterior shoulders which continue around to meet the flat back
of the button. Stamped on the reverse side and encircling the base of
the eye shank is a design of continuously interlacing stylized laurel
leaves. Other than this design, no other marks appear. The eye is formed
of a well-soldered loop, the shank of which is directly brazed to the
copper disc without any foot. This specimen was found in the open
central area of the fort.
Copper and Pearl Button
The single copper and pearl button measures 14 mm. in diameter (Fig.
43, g). it is characterized by having a mother of pearl disc
inset into a copper setting on the exterior face. The pearl disc is 11
mm. in diameter and has a design of 12 radiating loops or "fingers" out
into its face. The copper setting, arising from a slightly convex
reverse side, rounds at the margin shoulders and bevels upward to hold
and fit flush with the pearl inset. A single row of small contiguous
copper beads encircles the front of the copper setting on the bevelled
margin. The eye attachment on the back of the button is simply a
soldered loop brazed to the disc without any foot.
The provenience of this composite button is from within building II
near pit 15. It is thus in a Hudson's Bay Company context.
Plain Brass Buttons
A total of five plain brass buttons are represented in the sample
from Rocky Mountain House. Within this series there are five different
sizes and two different types of eye attachments. The following
descriptions are considered according to Olsen's (1963) and South's
(1964) classification of plain buttons and their eye form.
Type D (Olsen) or Type 7 (South). Four of the brass buttons
are of this type (Fig. 43, h). The discs are flat and range in
diameters through 13 mm., 14 mm., 15 mm. and 21 mm. Each has a brass
wire eye whose foot is inserted within and hidden by a cast boss on the
back of the button. Also present on the disc's back are a series of
concentric rings or striations left by a cutting tool.
Both Olsen and South consider brass buttons of this type to date
between 1720 and 1785. However, the proveniences of the above specimens
suggest a later date. The 21 mm. specimen is from building II near the
double-hearth fireplace, and the 14 mm. specimen is also from this building. The 15 mm.
brass button came from the area west of building II, while the smallest
(13 mm.) button comes from pit 6 within building III. The proveniences
within buildings II and III are datable to the Hudson's Bay Company
occupation of the fort.
Type G (Olsen) or Type 9 (South). The single specimen of this
type of plain brass button is also characterized by having a flat coin
shape (Fig. 43, i). This specimen has a diameter of 23 mm. The brass
wire eye is simply brazed to the back of the disc without any
accompanying foot or cast boss.
Olsen dates this plain brass button type between 1785 and 1800, a
date which again appears too early for the context in which the button
was found. It comes from the area encompassed by the northeastern end of
building V which was erected after the fort was extended. There remains
the possibility, however, that the button dates to the original
dimensions of the fort within which area it was recovered. It may simply
be a matter of chance that the button's position was later the site of
the Hudson's Bay Company erection of a new building. The precise
contextual dating of this specimen remains uncertain; it could be of
either North West Company or Hudson's Bay Company times.
Plain Iron Buttons
Other than the one GILT button with an iron base, all other iron
buttons recovered from the site are plain. The plain iron specimens
total six and display three types of eye attachments, two of which are
similar to those described for the
plain brass buttons. Since neither the Olsen nor South
classifications are helpful for these plain iron buttons, the specimens
are simply described below according to form and eye attachment.
Plain Iron Button with Drilled Eye. The single small specimen
of this button type measures 14 mm. in diameter (Fig. 43, j). Its
exterior face is flat while the reverse side is slightly concave. The
squarish eye attachment is moulded in one piece with the button disc and
has simply been drilled to produce the eye.
This specimen is from pit 4 within building II, thereby establishing
its temporal provenience to the Hudson's Bay Company occupation.
Plain Iron Buttons with Cast Boss. Two buttons of this type
are represented in the sample (Fig. 43, k). Each has a flat coin-like
shape with diameters measuring 14 mm. and 16 mm. The distinctive eye
attachment is similar to that on Olsen's (1964) Type D brass button. An
iron wire eye, whose foot is inserted into and hidden by a cast boss, is
the attachment. Concentric spun rigs on the back of the button disc are
not visible on these iron specimens.
The 16 mm. button is from pit 15 within building II, and thus is
assignable to the Hudson's Bay Company occupation of the fort.
Similarly, the 14 mm. specimen recovered from pit 6 within building III
is of late date.
Plain Iron Buttons with Wire Eye. Three specimens of this
button type complete the button descriptions (Fig. 43, l). These
specimens also are flat on both faces and have a simple well-soldered
wire eye brazed to the disc without any accompanying foot or insertion
bracket.
The single specimen of 15 mm. diameter is from the central area of
building II. The remaining two buttons, each 17 mm. wide, were found in pit 4
within building II, and in pit 6 of building III. Clearly all of these
specimens are of late provenience dating to Hudson's Bay Company
times.
Table 4: Button Distribution |
Provenience | Number |
|
Building II | 7 |
|
Building II (pit 4) | 5 |
|
Building II (pit 5) | 1 |
|
Building II (pit 15) | 1 |
|
Building III (pit 6) | 2 |
|
Building V (east end) | 2 |
|
North corner bastion | 1 |
|
Pit 8 | 1 |
|
Pit 10 | 1 |
|
Fort area west of building II | 3 |
|
Between building land pit 11 | 1 |
|
Open centre of fort | 1 |
|
Outside south end of fort | 1 |
|
Total | 27 |
|
Discussion
It is apparent that almost all the buttons from the site, either
decorated or plain, have proveniences indicative of being used and lost
during Hudson's Bay Company occupation. As the single most distinctive
button type, the silver Hudson's Bay Company coat and sleeve buttons
firmly establish that Company's occupancy of the fort and residence in
building II. Some of the plain brass buttons considered to be of early
date (1720-85) by Olsen and South have provenience at Rocky Mountain
House indicative of a much later period of use. This temporal
discrepancy is probably another direct reflection of the isolated nature
of the fort, away from the more advanced, style-concious eastern
centres, and the necessity to salvage and retain buttons for personal
use. Unfortunately, there is no one button from the site which may be
separated and conclusively stated to represent a relic of North West
Company occupation.
The distribution of buttons over the site shows an expected close
association with buildings. Specifically, 23 of the 27 buttons in the
sample are from building structures, particularly building II which
alone yielded 13 specimens. Four other structures, buildings III, V, VI
and the north corner bastion together yielded an
additional 10 buttons. This evidence strongly suggests that these
were areas within the fort where personnel resided or worked. While some
buttons were evidently lost in refuse pits, at least seven were cached
within personal pits in building II. Yet others appear to have been
lost inadvertently during normal activities inside and outside the
buildings.
44 Personal items, a, handmade lead cross from building II;
b, conical silver earring from pit 5 in building II; c,
watch winder from pit 1; d, silver loop earring from building II;
e, copper cufflink from near pit 2; f, copper band from
pit 6 in building III; g, brass pin with copper knob from pit 10;
h, three round iron needles.
(click on image for a PDF version)
|
Cufflinks
A single set of copper cufflinks (Fig. 44, e) is included in the
inventory of personal and household items from Rocky Mountain House.
This set is composed of two thin oval discs, each 17 mm. by 13 mm. The
copper discs are mould-made with an accompanying shank and drilled eye attachment on
the reverse side of each. Passing through these eyes to join the discs
together is a soldered copper wire loop 15 mm. in total length.
The central back portion of each disc is moulded into a depression.
Encircling this well, however, there is an outer rim in low relief 2 mm.
wide. Other than this moulding form, no other decoration or marks appear
on the reverse side of the discs.
The exterior face of each disc has the reverse form of the backs.
Around the outer margins each disc is depressed in a 2 mm. wide band
which rises in relief over the central body of each disc. These central
convex faces are plain. Moulded decoration occurs around the depressed
margins. Here the marginal rims are bordered by a single line of
contiguous, small upraised beads. Within this outer bead ring and
radiating centrally at right angles from it is an additional series of
parallel, elongated bead-like projections. These cross and continue
around the depressed margins of each disc.
This specimen was found just below the sod in the vicinity of pit 2
in the northwest corner of the fort. Undoubtedly it was once worn as a
sleeve link.
Lead Cross
Unique within the sample of personal artifacts is a homemade pendant
lead cross (Fig. 44, a). This specimen measures 4.5 cm. long by 5
mm. wide, and has been cut from a sheet of lead 2.5 mm. thick.
Distinctive of this cross is the fact that it has three horizontal bars,
each 14 mm. in length, spaced parallel to one another 9 mm. apart. A
small 0.5 mm. hole for suspension is located 3 mm. from the top of the
vertical shaft. No insignia or identifying marks occur on this specimen,
which was found loose in the south-central area of building II.
Earrings
Two styles of earrings are present among the three earrings recovered
from the site (Fig. 44, b, d). The first style, represented by a
single specimen, is made from a hollow cone of tarnished silver or
silver alloy. It measures 2.6 cm. long and tapers from a top diameter of
2.5 mm. to 7 mm. wide at the base. Closing off the base is a folded
circular flap joined in one piece to the side of the cone. The fold seam
running down the side of the cone is tightly annealed. Projecting from
the top of the cone is an iron wire loop for suspension. This particular
specimen came from pit 5 within building II.
Conical silver earrings such as this appear on many historic fur
trading sites dating between 1780 and 1870. Petersen (1964: 46)
illustrates one from Fort Mackinac (1781-1895); one is known from Fort
St. Joseph of 1796-1825 (Helen Devereux: personal communication);
Woolworth and Wood (1960: Pl. 60, f) illustrate three from Kipp's
Post (1826-30): and Smith (1960a: Pl. 28, j) illustrates an
identical specimen from Fort Pierre II (1858-63). It will be noted that
although the distribution of this type of earring is widespread through
time and geographic area, it never appears in quantity.
The second style of earring found at Rocky Mountain House is
represented by two specimens, both of silver. Each is composed of a 0.2
mm. thin circular band, 2.5 mm. wide, with an over-all ring diameter of
20 mm. Hanging from each ring is a silver strap-like pendant, also 2.5
mm. wide. This is attached by means of a bent loop around a slight
constriction in the main circular band. No identifying marks occur on
either of the two specimens found loose within building II.
Watch Winder
A brass winding key and pendant for an old-style pocket watch was
found (Fig. 44, c) The fob ring is missing. Total length of the
specimen is 3.1 cm. with the circular key-winding tube measuring 1.0 cm.
long by 3 mm. in diameter. The open socket at the end of this tube is
square. A circular brass disc 1.5 cm. wide by 1.5 mm. in thickness
immediately adjoins the key-winding tube and holds a 1 cm. wide
bluish-violet amethyst. This amethyst is cut in an octagonal pattern and
is visible on both sides of the pendant disc. A short circular 0.6 mm.
long projection extends from the brass disc in line with the main
key-winding tube. This specimen is from pit 1.
Copper Band
This copper band represents an attempt to fashion a homemade bracelet
(Fig. 44, f). Cut from a piece of sheet copper
0.5 mm. thick, the band measures 1.0 cm. wide by 12.6 cm. long. It is
folded to fit the wrist of a child or a person with a small wrist
diameter of 4.0 cm. This specimen was recovered from pit 6 within
building III.
Hawk Bells
Two small, severely crumpled bells occur in the artifact inventory.
The small copper specimen recovered from pit 6 within building III is damaged,
but is of hawk-bell size and was probably silver plated. Another small
specimen of 5 mm. diameter is of silver. This bell, too, is of hawk size
and comes from pit 10.
Needles
Four iron needles are present in the sample of artifacts (Fig. 44,
h). All but one are complete and all have a tapered sharpened point. The
needles are manufactured from round iron wire, but display different
methods of eye piercing.
The smallest needle, 4 cm. long by 1 mm. thick, is complete and
approaches modern needles in appearance. It has a distinctive fluting or
slot running parallel to the shank on two sides of the eye end, and
through these flutings a 0.5 mm. wide eye is perforated. This specimen
from pit 8 just outside the south gateway of the enlarged fort probably
is of late date.
The remaining three iron needles are all from the northwest corner of
the fort in and around buildings I and II. From building I is a needle 5
cm. long and 2 mm. thick. The 1 mm. wide eye is simply perforated
through a very slight flattening of the shank. This specimen is heavily
corroded.
A third specimen, 5.2 cm. long by 2 mm. thick, comes from the central
area of building II. This needle has the same style of eye perforation
as the specimen recovered from building I; the eye width is 1 mm.
The fourth and longest iron needle, 6 cm. long by 2 mm. thick, has
the eye portion broken off. This specimen was found in pit 1 behind
building I.
Pin
Only one pin occurs in the artifact sample (Fig. 44, g). This is a
brass straight pin with copper knob and broken tip. This broken pin
measures 15 mm. long by 1 mm. thick. The round copper knob at the butt
end of the pin has a diameter of 2 mm. and has been attached to the
shaft. This technique is indicative of a hand-made specimen, and thus
may pre-date 1824, for in that year, Mr. Lemuel Wright of Massachusetts
patented the first pin-making machine in England (Moore 1933: 123).
This specimen was recovered from pit 10 within building VI.
Forks
Two forks, each of a different style, were recovered from the
northwest corner of the fort and give a glimpse of the cutlery used at
the fort.
Folding Sheath Fork
This unique specimen of fine workmanship is an article which must
have been a prized pocket possession of its former owner. It is a
folding two-tinned steel fork originally covered by two decorated brass
foil side covers. One of the side covers is presently missing.
The slightly curved sheath of 10.2 cm. length measures 1.3 cm. wide
at its narrowest end and 1.5 cm. at the widest (hinge) end. The casing
is composed of an inner steel shank with depressed slots for spur
fittings of the two foil side covers. The preserved brass foil side
cover is very thin, 1 mm. and is elaborately embossed with a sinuous
floral and vine sign, terminating in a five-pointed flower or star. At
either end of the foil sheath in a 1.3 cm. square area, the design is
composed of five lines of contiguous upraised beads. A brass rivet
through these square areas at either end of the sheath holds the whole
assemblage together.
The 1.5 mm. thick rivet through the widest end of the sheath also
serves as a hinge for the fork blade. This rivet was removed during the
analysis to examine the fork blade in detail. In the photograph (Fig.
51, j), the fork blade is improperly inserted; its position
should be reversed.
The fork blade is flat, being 1 mm. thick, 8.2 cm. long, and 1 cm.
wide. The two tines extend for 4.6 cm. and taper to points 1.5 mm. wide.
Unfortunately, no identifying mark or letters appear on this specimen.
It was recovered in the drainage area running into pit 1.
Table Fork
The second style of fork is a straight shanked, two-tinned steel
table fork (Fig. 50, j). This well-preserved specimen is 19.1 cm.
long and is fitted with a two-piece antler handle. The handle measures
7.8 cm. long by 2.1 cm. in maximum width, and is composed of two antler
side pieces fixed to the central shank by two rivets. The butt end of
the shank is flattened to cap the antler handle.
The exposed portion of the shank is circular and has a length of 5.3
cm. It then bifurcates into two tines, each 4 mm. thick and extending an
additional 6 cm. These tapering tines are spaced 9 mm. apart.
No identifying letters or manufacturer's symbols occur on this
specimen. The presence of two tines, however, indicates that it is
earlier than the later three-tined fork found on other western forts of
post-1860 vintage (Smith 1960a: 134; 1960b: 221; Mills 1960: 40).
Straight-shanked, two-tinned forks are known from Fort Michilimackinac
of 1720-80 (Maxwell and Binford 1961 Pl. 14, k). The Rocky Mountain
House specimen is from the trench of the west exterior palisade near
drainage outlet 2.
Glass Vials
Two glass vials are represented, both of blown glass, one being
incomplete and the other undamaged.
The complete vial (Fig. 45, f) of clear blown glass is
cylindrical and measures 5.6 cm. long. The main body of the vial is 1.4
cm. in diameter by 4.7 cm. long. It rounds to a thick, flat bottom
displaying a pontil mark in the centre. The vial bottom is 5 mm.
thick.
The upper portion of this vial has a constricted neck and outflaring
rim. The neck measures 7 mm. high and has a diameter of 9 mm. Topping
the neck is a flared rim of 1.5 cm. diameter. This rim is not uniform in
width across the top of the neck and projects noticeably on one side.
The thickness of the glass rim is 2 mm., while the small bore measures 4
mm. in width. This fine specimen from pit 5 within building II probably
represents a small medicine, perfume or condiment vial.
The second glass vial, (Fig. 45, g) is represented only by the
neck and rim section. Its dimensions indicate that it is a larger vial
than the specimen previously discussed, but again it is circular, of
clear blown glass and has an irregular rim.
The neck measures 1 cm. high by 1.5 cm. in diameter with the glass
being 1.5 mm. thick. The adjoining rim flares outwardly for an average
diameter of 2.1 cm. The orifice in this 2 mm. thick rim measures 1.1 cm.
in diameter.
The specimen comes from the 30 in. depth of pit 6 within building
III.
45 Ceramics and glass. a, black basalt stone-ware sherd from pit
10 (1767-1810): b, rim sherd of grey salt-glazed stoneware from
ash deposit underlying building IV (1800-50); c, rim sherd of
undecorated lead-glazed earthenware; d, sherd of white unglazed
stoneware; e, ceramic button of underglazed creamware decorated
with blue transfer printing from building II: f, complete glass
vial from pit 5 in building II; g, portion of glass vial from pit
6 in building III; h, bottom of lettered bottle; i,
portion of squared green bottle from pit 5 in building II; j,
clear window glass from building I; k, portion of round clear
glass bottle bottom; l, portion of round purple glass bottle.
(click on image for a PDF version)
|
Glass Bottles
A total of five distinct bottles occur in the Rocky Mountain House
glassware sample. Four of these may be stated definitely to date to the
Hudson's Bay Company period of occupancy, and it is very probable that
the fifth, a lettered bottle, also dates to this period. Seventeen
additional fragments of bottle glass cannot be ascribed to specific
bottles.
Lettered Bottle
This moulded glass bottle (Fig. 45, h) is represented by a
broken basal portion, misshapen from heating. The bottle is square with
each opaque side measuring 1.8 cm. wide by 2 mm. thick. The remaining
height of the bottle is 2.6 cm.
Appearing on all four sides of the bottle are capital letters moulded
in relief, presumably identifying a manufacturer's name or the nature of
the contents. None of these lettered words is complete. In the
illustration cited above, the capital letters ATH appear on the
uppermost side. Proceeding clockwise from this,the letters EI are
visible: clockwise again from this face are the letters HN; and,
finally, the fourth side carries the letters BY. Attempts to trace the
identity and meaning of these letters have been unrewarding.
This bottle is from the area between the north corner bastion and the
northeast end of building II. It probably represents a container for
some type of patent medicine.
Squared Green Bottle
This bottle specimen (Fig. 45, i) is represented by only one piece,
a side fragment of dark olive green coloured glass exhibiting many
interior oval bubbles. The glass is 2.5 mm. thick and the recovered
portion displays two vertically bevelled corners giving the bottle a
squared form. The intact side measures 3.5 cm. high by 2.0 cm. wide
between its two bevelled corners.
This bottle, recovered from pit 5 within building II, may have held
liquor.
Round Green Bottle
This bottle is represented by nine fragmented pieces, none of which
fit together. The glass is a light green colour filled with many air
bubbles, and ranges from 3 mm. to 4.5 mm. in thickness. From these
measurements and the curvature of some of the fragments, this bottle
was a heavy, round container. One of the glass fragments (specimen 671)
has been worked along one edge.
The fragments of this bottle came from the upper level of pit 10
underlying building VI.
Round Clear Glass Bottle
Half of the bottom and 11 fragments are all that remain of this
circular bottle of clear glass with a light greenish tint (Fig. 45, k).
The glass bottom is a very thick 7 mm., and has a basally concave
indentation of 7 mm. The diameter of the bottle is 6.7 cm. across the
bottom. Appearing on opposite sides of the bottle are two vertical lines indicating
that the bottle was manufactured in a two-section mould.
This bottle is from the southeast end of building V, dating to the
Hudson's Bay Company rebuilding of the fort.
Purple Glass Bottle
This bottle is represented by a basal portion and 14 fragments, many
of which are highly distorted through melting (Fig. 45, l). Purpling of
glass apparently occurs as a result of a heating reaction by sunlight or
fire on the manganese oxide in the glass (Fontana et al. 1962: 100).
Thus the purple colour of this bottle is not its original colour.
The bottle's base measures 7 mm. thick by 6.4 cm. wide. It is flat
and displays a thin encircling mould ring 3.3 cm. in diameter. Two
vertical mould lines up opposite sides indicate that the bottle was made
in a two-section mould.
The pieces of this bottle were found loose in the area between
building IV and the interior security wall flanking the west side of the
south gateway.
Other Bottle Fragments
In addition to the identifiable bottles, there are 17 loose
fragments. Briefly these may be subdivided into clear and green bottle
glass. Two pieces of the clear glass are from pit 8; one from the ash
fill of pit 11; one from building II; one from the open centre of the
fort; one from the vicinity of the surface ash deposit north of building
V, and five others are loose splinters of uncertain provenience.
Of the loose green bottle glass fragments, one is from building II;
one from north of the south gateway; two from the vicinity of the surface ash
deposit north of building V; one from the surface ash deposit in
building IV, and one from near the surface ash deposit by the fur press
base. Noticeably, many of the green glass fragments have a close
association with surface ash deposits.
Ceramics
Only nine ceramic sherds were recovered from Rocky Mountain House.
This small sample is in part probably a reflection of the 1,000-mile
distance between the fort and the headwaters of the Great Lakes. The
numerous breakage possibilities during transit over this long canoe
route no doubt made ceramics a very select and valued commodity. Its
limited occurrence at Rocky Mountain House suggests that ceramics were
personal luxury items.
The small ceramics sample yields additional inferences reflecting
the nature of the fort itself. Too, one would not expect to find large
quantities of china in a rude seasonal outpost for handling furs or an
interior depot for transmountain exploration. Such would be expected to
characterize the more sedentary and permanent forts (e.g., Fort
Edmonton, Fort Garry).
Black Basalt Stoneware
One sherd of this ware was recovered in the plough zone covering pit
10 under building VI (Fig. 45, a). The sherd is very thin, measuring 2
mm. in thickness. Mrs. Vanderburgh states that this ware, sometimes
called "Egyptian Black," was made by many 18th-century Staffordshire
potteries, and that its manufacture continued into the 19th century.
Its shape indicates that it may have been from a tea-pot, sugar bowl or cream
jug.
Table 5: Ceramics from Rocky Mountain House |
Sherd No. |
| Ware Type | Date |
|
883 | 1 |
Black basalt stoneware | 1767-1810 |
|
403 | 1 |
Grey salt-glaze stoneware | 1800-1850 |
|
836 | 1 |
White salt-glaze ware | 1850-1900 |
|
627 | 1 |
White unglazed stoneware | ? |
|
642 204 815 | 3 |
Undecorated lead-glaze earthenware |
|
|
935 328 | 2 |
Decorated underglazed creamware with blue transfer printing | prior to 1850 |
|
Grey Salt-Glazed Stoneware
The single sherd of this ware was found in the ash deposit adjoining
post 43 of building IV (Fig. 45, b). The sherd represents a rim
fragment, the body of which is 3 mm. thick, and the rim lip 3.5 mm.
thick. The rim lip has been fashioned by folding the clay over the lip
and down the exterior of the sherd for a distance of 5 mm. Commencing 1
cm. below the folded rim on the exterior is a series of finely etched
parallel bands spaced approximately 2 mm. apart and encircling the
bowl.
This type of stoneware was made throughout the 18th century. The
folded rim is associated with early stoneware, and may be from a small
bowl or cup.
White Salt-Glazed Stoneware
One very small fragment of this type of stoneware was found in the
plough zone within the eastern end of building II. It measures 3 mm. in
thickness.
Much white salt-glazed stoneware was made in the 18th century for
table use, and in the 19th century, for more utilitarian purposes.
White Unglazed Stoneware
The single sherd of this ware was recovered in the plough zone
within the vicinity of the south gateway (Fig. 45, d). it is quite thick,
4 mm., and massive. The sherd is from a flat plate or platter, and may
have a thin wash of lead glaze, but this is difficult to determine.
Undecorated Lead-Glazed Earthenware
Three sherds of this ware were recovered over different sections of
the fort (Fig. 45, c). The rim sherd illustrated came from building IV,
and the two body fragments from the northern end of the fort northeast
of building II. The rim sherd measures 3 mm. in body thickness, as does
one of the body fragments; the other body sherd measures 3.5 mm. thick.
The two body sherds are too small to identify with any particular shape,
but the rim sherd again has the interesting folded rim that occurs on
the grey salt-glazed stoneware. This rim sherd is also probably from a
bowl or cup.
This earthenware was developed in the second half of the 19th century
by many English potters, and became the most common earthenware of the
period 1765 to 1820.
Decorated Underglazed Creamware with Transfer Printing
Two pieces of this ware were recovered from the plough zone within
the northwest corner of the barracks-like building II (Fig. 45, e). Each sherd
measures 3 mm. in thickness. The sherd illustrated has been ground down
into a circular form, 12 mm. in diameter, presumably for use as a button
or bead. The centre of the white glazed interior face of the disc has
been partially drilled through. The hole represented is 1.5 mm. wide and
quite shallow. These sherds may date from before 1850 because of the
thickness of the pottery and the colour of the blue transfer
printing.
Discussion
It is apparent from this analysis that all of the ceramics found at
Rocky Mountain House are of English origin and manufacture. The
temporal range falls between 1765 and 1850, well within the known life
span of the fort. Of particular interest is the black basalt stoneware
which was manufactured between 1765 and 1810. Its occurrence within the
upper levels of pit 10 underlying building VI tends to support the
belief that this pit dates to the North West Company occupation in the
fort. On the other hand, a late appearance of this ware and others on
the site may be due to temporal lag between the time of manufacture and
the time at which ceramics reached Rocky Mountain House.
The suggested forms are also interesting. The few identifiable forms
include bowls or cups, a plate and either a teapot or sugar bowl. These
items are rather finer than one would expect to be in the personal
retinue of a voyageur. The excavated ceramic material is noticeably
associated with buildings II and IV.
|